Skip to Content

50 Best Non-Candy Easter Basket Ideas to Avoid the Sugar Rush

There's no sugar, but they're still super sweet!

By
the sunbasil peeps shaped soap and the schleich bayala eggs are two good housekeeping picks for best non candy easter giftspinterest

We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.

When it comes time to start filling Easter baskets, the first thing that comes to mind is chocolate eggs. And maybe chocolate bunnies. Or jellybeans. Or Peeps. Or candy, candy and more candy. Whether you've had your fill of sweet treats or are looking to avoid sugary snacks, it might be time to think about some Easter gifts for kids that aren't edible.

These are the best non-candy Easter basket ideas for 2024. Luckily, there are so many wonderful things that fit inside an Easter basket, or even a plastic egg. There are tons of cute goodie bag-style favors that you can buy in packs of 12 or more, which makes them good for class parties or giveaways. There are some collectibles that come pre-packaged in their own eggs, which saves you some time and effort. And even some Good Housekeeping Best Toy Award-winning items that fit the Easter theme — and have been tested in the Good Housekeeping Institute labs and with real families for safety, durability and fun. Put them all together, and they won't even realize they're missing out on the sugar.

Looking for more great Easter gift ideas? Check out these Good Housekeeping guides:

Easter Gifts for Babies | Easter Gifts for Toddlers | Easter Gifts for Boys | Easter Gifts for Teens

Fun Family Game

Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza: Easter Edition!

Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza: Easter Edition!
Fun Family Game

Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza: Easter Edition!

$10 at Amazon
Credit: Taco Cat Goat Cheese Pizza

Families love playing this game: Say the words, flip over the cards, and if the words and picture on the card happen to coincide, players race to slap the pile first and collect the tiles. This version gives the game an Easter twist, with cards that make players make bunny ears, flap wings and play Easter eggs before they can slap the pile. Ages 7+

This fiery dragon egg is impressive enough on its own, but open it and you'll find 12" articulated dragon inside. You can get them in several different colors, too, including gold, blue, rainbow and pastel candy colors. Ages 6+

Good Housekeeping Best Toy Award Winner

Spin Flip Puzzle

Spin Flip Puzzle
Good Housekeeping Best Toy Award Winner

Spin Flip Puzzle

Credit: TCG Toys

Good Housekeeping Institute testers were mesmerized by the way the concentric rings of these puzzles twist and flip until they form a two-sided picture. Multiple testers said they were passed around the whole family, and often families would get two and try to do head-to-head speed competitions. Ages 8+

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
A Clear Favorite Among Kids

Paint by Sticker Kids: Easter

Paint by Sticker Kids: Easter
A Clear Favorite Among Kids

Paint by Sticker Kids: Easter

Give your little Picasso a mess-free activity: Here, they can bring 10 Easter scenes to life with an assortment of mosaic-like colored stickers. Ages 5+

Good for an Easter Party Favor

Animal Building Blocks Easter Eggs

Animal Building Blocks Easter Eggs
Good for an Easter Party Favor

Animal Building Blocks Easter Eggs

Now 30% Off
Credit: JOYIN

These eggs come pre-filled with all the pieces they'll need to build some kind of creature, which will give them something to do after they've found all the Easter Bunny's hiding spots. You can find unicorns, rabbits, dinosaurs and a variety of other animals, or get a similar set with construction vehicles. Ages 3+

Non-Candy Easter Gift Under $10

DoodleJamz JellyBoards

Best Seller
DoodleJamz JellyBoards
Non-Candy Easter Gift Under $10

DoodleJamz JellyBoards

Credit: Sky Castle

Kids of all ages enjoy the sensory experience of pushing patterns into the colored gel with these boards. There's a stylus they can use, though some think it's more fun to just use your fingers. It also comes in five different gel colors. Ages 3+

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Squishmallows But Cuter

Squishmallows Squishville Honor Roll Squad

On Sale
Squishmallows Squishville Honor Roll Squad
Squishmallows But Cuter

Squishmallows Squishville Honor Roll Squad

Credit: Jazwares

One of the things that kids like most about Squishmallows is that they're vaguely Easter egg-shaped. If you don't want to fill the basket with one big Squishmallows, you can go for this pack of six, two-inch versions. They're the perfect size to squeeze into a plastic egg. Ages 3+

Great Goodie Bag Gift

Kinetic Sand Eggs

Kinetic Sand Eggs
Great Goodie Bag Gift

Kinetic Sand Eggs

Now 19% Off
Credit: Kinetic Sand

Crack these eggs open to find sand that feels like the perfect moisture for shaping and molding. This comes in a whopping pack of 20 eggs, making them great giveaways, and each one has either red, yellow or blue sand inside. Ages 3+

Cute for Tweens or Teens

Rabbit Slipper Socks

On Sale
Rabbit Slipper Socks
Cute for Tweens or Teens

Rabbit Slipper Socks

Now 24% Off
Credit: Journey Studio

Forget your old bunny slippers; these rabbit socks are ultra-toasty. Plus, they come in several colors. No age recommendation given

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For LEGO Fans

LEGO Creator Easter Chick

LEGO Creator Easter Chick
For LEGO Fans

LEGO Creator Easter Chick

Now 40% Off
Credit: LEGO

LEGO fans will thrill to have this spring-themed set in their collection. It's just 52 pieces, which means it's the perfect thing to put together after their egg hunts are over. Ages 6+

Cute for Preschoolers

Bizyboo Seek & Find Plush

Bizyboo Seek & Find Plush
Cute for Preschoolers

Bizyboo Seek & Find Plush

Credit: Vango

The perfect diversion! Kids can squeeze and push the filling in the bag around while looking for the objects listed on the tag. It's an "I Spy" game and a fidget toy in one! Ages 3+

Meaningful Non-Candy Easter Gift

Morning Mantras Cards

Morning Mantras Cards
Meaningful Non-Candy Easter Gift

Morning Mantras Cards

Credit: Affirmators!

For 30 days straight, they can pick a card from this deck and read their daily intention over breakfast. Then they can recite their intention throughout the day when they need a mood boost. No age recommendation given

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
For Crafty Kids

DIY Squishies

DIY Squishies
For Crafty Kids

DIY Squishies

Credit: WATINC

No, the squishy trend still isn't over — in fact, it's gotten even more creative. These cream-scented squishies come blank, so kids can use their own art supplies to color and decorate them. You get 30 pieces in this set. Ages 3+

Musical Toy for Preschoolers

Wooden Egg Shakers

Wooden Egg Shakers
Musical Toy for Preschoolers

Wooden Egg Shakers

Now 30% Off
Credit: Joyin

When your kiddo gives these painted wooden eggs a shake, they'll discover their own sense of rhythm. Cue to the post-brunch dance parties. Ages 3+

Trendy Gift

Hatchimals Alive Hatch N’ Stroll Play Set

On Sale
Hatchimals Alive Hatch N’ Stroll Play Set
Trendy Gift

Hatchimals Alive Hatch N’ Stroll Play Set

Credit: Spin Master

Kids will love hatching the pair of included eggs by removing the pacifiers, filling the bottles with water, and "feeding" them to life. After the two characters are hatched, they can be wheeled around in the included stroller. There's also a play set with a high chair instead of stroller, or a big carton of five hatching eggs ($20) if you need to rally fill a basket. Ages 3+

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Sweet Non-Candy Treat

OOLY Macaron Erasers

OOLY Macaron Erasers
Sweet Non-Candy Treat

OOLY Macaron Erasers

Credit: OOLY

The pastel, macaron-shaped erasers will be a sweet upgrade to their school bags — they even smell like vanilla! They also pull-apart, so kids can mix and match the tops and bottoms. No age recommendation given

Good Housekeeping Kids' Book Award Winner

'Search for a Giant Squid' Book

On Sale
'Search for a Giant Squid' Book
Good Housekeeping Kids' Book Award Winner

'Search for a Giant Squid' Book

Now 10% Off
Credit: Chronicle Books

The decisions kids make in this book will take them on different paths through the story, all focused on looking for the great giant squid (and learning about the ocean along the way). “Every time I tried to stop, they wanted to start over on a different adventure!” one parent tester said. Ages 6+

RELATED: The Good Housekeeping Best Kids' Book Awards

Great for On-the-Go

Melissa & Doug Water Wow! Activity Pad

On Sale
Melissa & Doug Water Wow! Activity Pad
Great for On-the-Go

Melissa & Doug Water Wow! Activity Pad

Credit: Melissa & Doug

Great for waiting rooms, the car or at restaurants, these spiral books contain pictures that color in like magic: Just fill the included paintbrush with water, and kids can use it to reveal colors and hidden pictures. there are many themes to choose from, and you can also buy them in three-pack bundles for $16.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
STEM-Themed Easter Gift

National Geographic Geode Science Kit

National Geographic Geode Science Kit
STEM-Themed Easter Gift

National Geographic Geode Science Kit

Credit: National Geographic

In a way, aren't geodes like Easter eggs? You open them up to find beautiful surprises inside. This set comes with four geodes to break open, so kids can see the variety of crystals inside, along with safety goggles and an activity guide that teaches kids more about rocks and minerals. Ages 8+

Perfect Bedtime Read

'A Bedtime Hug for You!' Board Book

'A Bedtime Hug for You!' Board Book
Perfect Bedtime Read

'A Bedtime Hug for You!' Board Book

Now 25% Off
Credit: Tiger Tales

Good Housekeeping testers couldn't get enough of the touch-and-feel element of this book: the puppet arms, which get long each time you turn the page. The board book, a previous Good Housekeeping Kids' Book Award winner, features different animal parents sending their babies off to bed, so it's a good one to read after all the Easter excitement has died down.

Watch Next
 
preview for Good Housekeeping US Section: Holidays
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Easter 2024 Ideas

high angle view of greeting card with easter eggs on yellow background

106 Best Easter Messages and Wishes

easter bunny with eggs and decoration

The History of the Easter Bunny

easter games lead image

37 Egg-citing Easter Games Everyone Will Love

children eating chocolate easter egg

100 Best Easter Puns for Every Bunny

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below